The Marte family took a risk the other night. They went to eat.
The last time they went out, things quickly unraveled. The queso arrived but the tortilla chips did not. The waiters delivered enchiladas they didn’t order. When the family complained, their waiter shrugged.
The bill was over $50 without tip – a lot for working parents with two young children.
“That’s why takeout is usually a better option for us,” Jessica Marte said of settling into a booth at Chili’s Grill & Bar in a suburb north of Atlanta. “The food is not the problem. Mostly it’s the service.”
The patience customers have shown restaurants in recent years is waning, especially as menu prices soar and experienced workers become harder to find. From the dining rooms of America comes a plaintive cry: Can we get some service here?
And not just any service. Guests say they long for a night out with no QR codes, no waiters who don’t seem to care, and menus designed to glorify the chef and attract influencers. They want to feel like welcome guests again, wrapped in the warm, competent hospitality they dreamed of when the pandemic took everything away.
Some restaurant owners say they are looking for ways to recreate and even improve this essential part of the experience, despite struggling to train a new generation of waiters, hosts and chefs. They’re retiring robotic waiters, making dining rooms cozier, and freeing up waiters and bartenders to spend more time with customers.
“We’ve been giving restaurants a pass for many, many months, and I think we’ve gotten to a point where people really miss the human touch and the little details,” said Ed Lee, a chef and author who owns his spends time between Louisville, Kentucky. , and Washington, DC
Just how much small gestures mean, Mr. Lee saw on day one this month when he opened Nami, a Korean steakhouse in Louisville. A woman held the restaurant’s oversized, stylized menu to her cheek and murmured, “Oh, a menu!”
In Norcross, a small town north of Atlanta, Alexis Anin has just opened Influence, an Afro-Latin American restaurant and club where he does everything he can to make people feel like going out is a better idea, than staying at home. He made sure the cabins looked luxurious and the lighting was flattering but not too dim. He set up a small terrace for the Covid-cautious who still don’t feel comfortable eating inside.
“You have to come up with various tricks to keep them in your building,” he said. This includes making them feel safe. Although the area is not considered dangerous, he posted a security guard at the front door.
“I want guests to feel safe, so they know they’re going to have fun and that nothing will come of it,” he said.
However, fun has become expensive. Eating out cost 8.6 percent more in April than a year ago, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. In places that charge service fees on top of wages, the vignette shock is even worse.
“I want to support all of these service fee initiatives and better working conditions for people,” said Liza Dunning, creative director in the Bay Area. “But also, wow – how much do I pay for a fried chicken now?”
Leann Emmert and Katrina Elder, who work in the film industry, spent weekends trying out the newest restaurants in Los Angeles. But now that a few drinks and sharing an entree and appetizer can easily cost $200 with no guarantee of good service, that’s changed. The pair have mostly stuck to one neighborhood restaurant, which serves consistently good food and feels like everyone knows their name.
“I don’t want to spend my money in a place that doesn’t know how to make people feel cared for,” Ms. Emmert said.
Will Guidara, the New York restaurateur who published Unreasonable Hospitality: The Remarkable Power of Giving People More Than They Expect in 2022, said the value proposition of dining out has changed. “Good food without hospitality is not of great value,” he said.
But how do you teach true hospitality to a new generation of workers who may not even know how to fold a napkin?
Slang like “86”—meaning the cuisine consists of a specific dish—could just as easily be a new language. Mr. Lee recently explained to a waitress who’s just starting out that she doesn’t have to ask the customer’s permission every time she refills the water glasses.
The need for more attentive service hasn’t escaped Chili’s executives. One measure of how its 1,129 restaurants are doing is the reports the company generates on “Guests with a problem,” or G-WAPs. A year ago, the G-WAP value rose so much that immediate action was needed. A lack of attention from staff was high on the list.
Kevin Hochman, who had just become CEO, took a few steps. He canceled a pilot program using robots as servers. He urged managers to hire staff to serve tables, a job that’s largely been left to servers in recent years. He simplified both the tablets waiters use to take orders and the way some dishes are prepared and served.
The aim was to give the waiters more time for the guests.
“When you go out to eat, you want to be served, and that hasn’t changed,” said Mr. Hochman. “People have lowered those expectations a little bit because of the work and staffing situation, but I think that’s sort of over now. They want a fast, fun and welcoming atmosphere.”
For 16 years, Jasmine Owens has been a bartender at the same Chili’s where the Marte family dined (which they loved, by the way).
“Things are better day and night,” she said. The team she works with is more cohesive and customers are happier — especially compared to the early days of the pandemic, when staff were swamped in takeout orders and customers were so nervous they were screaming and throwing away food.
Even chain restaurants are adopting a concept that was considered radical five years ago: kitchen culture needs to become friendlier and less militaristic, and waiters can’t shower their customers with love if they can’t feel that love at work.
That means better pay, coupled with mental health support, employee affinity groups, and fun after-school activities that don’t involve post-shift drinks.
“The conventional wisdom was, ‘Leave your problems at home and come here to work,'” said Mr. Lee. “Now we’re doing the opposite, so to speak. Bring your problems to work. Before the shift and at the family dinner, I want you to tell me what’s going on at your place. is your mother sick Has your pet died? So if you start acting weird during the service, I know why.”
It’s a time-consuming and less profitable way to lead, at least in the beginning. “But in the long run,” he said, “if I don’t utilize my staff, they stay longer and I save money.”
Still, in an industry plagued by inflation and riddled with “Help Wanted” signs, labor costs can be overwhelming for restaurateurs.
Craig and Annie Stoll, who founded the popular pizza and pasta restaurant Pizzeria Delfina in San Francisco’s Mission District in 1998, had trouble finding waiters for their newest Palo Alto branch, in part because they pooled tips to determine compensation between chefs and compensate waiters.
So they developed a waiter-less system, where guests typed in their own orders while lower-paid waiters and food delivery guys tended the tables.
“People didn’t like it,” Mr. Stoll said.
As business picked up, they reinstated waiters, who lured them by readjusting the tipping formula.
“People were much, much happier,” he said. “They wanted that warm service. It’s what people crave.”
Sam Hart, the chef who owns Counter- and Biblio in Charlotte, North Carolina, has taken a counterintuitive approach: He puts guests last.
First on the list of the “seven priorities” is employees and their mental health. The idea is that when a restaurant’s entire ecosystem is functioning smoothly, diners never realize they’re not front and center — a concept similar to what restaurateur Danny Meyer suggested in his 2006 book Setting the Table called “enlightened hospitality”.
But Mr. Hart believes some guests need to know exactly why they aren’t the priority. In a recent column in the Charlotte Observer, he took it head on with the title “Post Shutdown Diner.”
“It’s gotten to a point where something needs to be said: An ever-increasing number of reckless guests are destroying the hospitality industry,” he wrote. He listed 13 things customers shouldn’t do while dining, including snapping their fingers to get the waiter’s attention, threatening to leave a negative review, and “believing you own the place.”
Akila Stewart, a waitress at Manhattan’s Gramercy Tavern, doesn’t believe in the idea that the pandemic has created a new class of particularly discerning customers. “You’re always going to meet someone who’s probably having a bad day,” she said. “It’s just the nature of the business.”
She says customers today are more talkative, care about how she’s doing, and generally more grateful. “They are more aware that it could be taken away,” she said.
It nearly disappeared from one of Manhattan’s oldest and most popular Jewish food stands. Eisenberg’s, which opened on lower Fifth Avenue in 1928, closed its doors for good at the height of the pandemic.
Eric Finkelstein and Matt Ross, owners of a small chain of sandwich shops called Court Street Grocers, came to the rescue. They took over the deli, renamed it S&P Lunch (after the original owners), and reopened it last September.
They’ve been careful to keep the vintage red vinyl stools at the 40-foot counter and have given a slight overhaul to the large, eccentric menu, which features what many call the best tuna melt in town. To the relief of the regulars, they rehired Jodi Freedman-Viera, Eisenberg’s longtime, stalwart cashier, who every guest has to pay before they leave.
But most of her crew were new, and many of them were starting out in hospitality at a time when service meant touch-free ordering, wearing face masks and keeping customers as far away as possible.
At S&P, the service style is relaxed, friendly and analogue as far as possible.
“Conventional business wisdom says that everything is based on the algorithm,” said Mr. Finkelstein, “but what people really want is humanism.”
Follow New York Times Cooking on Instagram, Facebook, YouTube, TikTok and Pinterest. Get regular updates from The New York Times Cooking with recipe suggestions, cooking tips, and shopping tips.